Your Financial Plan Changed. Has Your Life Insurance Kept Up?
A permanent policy bought years ago was sized for the life you had then. When an older IUL or whole life policy deserves a checkup, what to ask the insurer for, and what a review is not.
Cornerstone Capital EditorialPublished Updated 4 min read

A permanent life insurance policy is built to last a lifetime. The plan it was bought for usually is not. Children grow up, a business is sold, a mortgage is paid, income rises or falls, a marriage ends or begins. The policy keeps doing what it was designed to do on the day you applied, whether or not that is still the job.
This is not about the policy you bought last month; that has its own article. This is about the indexed universal life or whole life policy you bought ten or twenty years ago and have not opened since.
Why permanent policies drift
Funding. Indexed universal life has flexible premiums, which means nothing forces the premium that keeps it healthy. If caps or participation rates fell after issue, or charges rose with age, the premium you set years ago may no longer be enough. Whole life has fixed premiums, but a policy that has been borrowed against, or that relied on dividends to pay for itself, can be off course too.
Loans. A loan taken for a good reason in 2015 and never repaid has been accruing interest since. It reduces the death benefit, and if it grows faster than the cash value the policy can lapse with the loan outstanding, which can create taxable income.
Beneficiaries and ownership. The person named at 35 may not be the person you would name today. A minor child named directly, a former spouse, a parent who has died, a trust that no longer exists: each sends money to the wrong place or into court.
Purpose. A policy sized to protect a young family and a large mortgage may be the wrong size, in either direction, for someone whose children are grown and whose estate has questions of its own.
What to ask the insurer for
An in-force illustration. It is the single most useful document in a review, and the insurer will provide it on request. It shows, from today forward, what the policy's values and death benefit are projected to do at the current premium. Ask for the guaranteed column beside the projected one, and, for an IUL, a run at a lower crediting rate than the default.
Also ask for the current annual statement, which shows the cash value, any loan and its interest, the current charges and the premium paid, and a beneficiary confirmation in writing.
What a review looks at
For every policy: the owner, the insured, the beneficiaries, the death benefit, the premium and the riders. For a permanent policy: whether it stays in force at the current premium on the guaranteed column; what the loan, if any, is doing; whether the cash value is doing what you expected; and whether the design still matches the purpose.
Often the answer is that nothing needs to change, and that is a good result. Sometimes the answer is to add premium, reduce the death benefit, repay or restructure a loan, update a beneficiary, or use a feature the policy already has. Rarely, after a side-by-side comparison, it is to replace the policy.
What a review is not
It is not a sales appointment for a new policy. Replacing an old permanent policy restarts charges and surrender periods, starts a new contestability period, and prices the coverage on your age and health today. FINRA's guidance on exchanging a policy lists the questions to ask anyone who proposes one. Nothing should be cancelled, surrendered or allowed to lapse before new coverage is approved, accepted, paid for and in force, and before the old and new have been compared in writing.
Why a periodic checkup is worth it
Illustrative scenario, not a real customer. A man in his sixties bought an IUL at 45 to cover a mortgage and his children's years at home. The mortgage is paid and the children are grown. The in-force illustration shows the policy will lapse at 78 at the current premium, because caps fell after issue and he never adjusted. He has choices he did not know he had: fund it properly for a smaller legacy benefit, reduce the benefit to what the premium supports, or let it run and plan around the lapse with his CPA. Each is reasonable. Not knowing was the only bad option.
Life changed. The policy did not announce it. A review every few years, and after any major change, is how you find out while there is still time to decide.
Next step
If you own an IUL or whole life policy and have not looked at it in a while, review your existing policy. The questions now include whether your permanent policy is funded and on track. No policy numbers, no uploads, a result before anyone asks how to reach you, and keep the policy in force while you look.
Keep in mind
Policy terms vary by insurer and state, and the contract governs. Illustrated non-guaranteed values are not guarantees; any contractual guarantees are backed by the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer. Loans and withdrawals reduce cash value and death benefit and can have tax consequences, particularly on lapse, surrender or modified endowment contract status. This article is general education, not tax, legal or investment advice.
Send this to someone
Before you decide
Questions to ask yourself
- 01When did I last see an in-force illustration for this policy?
- 02Is the policy on track to stay in force at the premium I am paying, on the guaranteed column as well as the projected one?
- 03Is there a loan outstanding, and what is it doing to the death benefit?
- 04Do the owner, the insured and the beneficiaries still match my intentions?
- 05Has the purpose I bought it for changed: a child grown, a business sold, a mortgage paid?
- 06If someone proposes replacing it, have I seen the old and new policies side by side, in writing?
Common questions
- What is an in-force illustration?
- A projection the insurer prepares for a policy that already exists, showing how its values and death benefit are expected to behave from today forward at the current premium, with a guaranteed column and one or more projected columns. It is the first document any review of a permanent policy needs.
- My IUL's cash value went down. Is something wrong?
- Not necessarily. Charges come out every month whether or not interest is credited, so cash value can decline in a year when the index is flat or negative, even with a 0 percent floor. What matters is whether the policy stays funded over time, which the in-force illustration shows.
- Should I replace an old policy with a new one?
- Only after a side-by-side comparison in writing, and never before the new coverage is approved, accepted and in force. A new policy means new charges, a new surrender period, a new contestability period and underwriting at an older age. Keeping what you have is often the right outcome.
Related coverage
- Policy ReviewA structured look at what you own and whether it still matches your household today.
- Indexed Universal LifePermanent coverage with cash-value potential, designed around your goals, with the limits explained.
- Whole LifeWhole life: lifelong coverage with cash value, higher premiums and more to understand.
Sources
4 sources and further reading
- Should you exchange your life insurance policy?, FINRA
- Consumer insight: life insurance, National Association of Insurance Commissioners
- Indexed universal life insurance, Investor.gov, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
- Life insurance and disability insurance proceeds, Internal Revenue Service
Links go to independent sources. Cornerstone Capital does not control and is not responsible for their content.
This article is general information, not individualized insurance, investment, legal, accounting or tax advice. Products, features and availability vary by state and carrier. Eligibility and premium depend on underwriting, and approval is never guaranteed. Consult qualified professionals about your own situation.

Next step
Start with a conversation.
Tell us about your household or business. A licensed broker will listen first, then walk through what may be available to you.
Not sure what to ask for? Start with your situation
Or call (501) 476-1468